After I used Emacs, Eclipse and Intellij Idea for a period of time. I gradually found some of their best features that we use everyday. I found Intellij idea is quite good, but it’s heavy and not very suitable for editing some kind of files(ruby, for instance). I like Emacs but when I use it, I found some features and key bindings are not well designed to be very efficient (at least for me). So I decide to add those features and change the key bindings to make it more comfortable to use it.
Here are some features that I think a good editor or IDE should have:
- Move(word, sentence, sexp, paragraph, page).
- Transpose(line, that is to move one line upward or downward)
- Mark (word, string, sexp, paragraph, page, whole document, C-w in idea)
- Delete(word, space, empty lines, one line, zap to char)
- Insert(split line, open line, duplicate one line)
- Case change(word, region)
- Live template. I like to invoke the template by pressing <tab>
- Auto completion. Auto completion was bound to C-SPC in idea,
alt-enter in eclipse. There should be only one key binding for all
kinds of auto completion. If there are multiple choices, there
should be some easy way to choose what you really want.
- auto completion while typing. like pabbrev
- for pairing tags like xml tags, finish typing the first part should invoke the insertion of the second part and the cursor should stay between them in the end.
- library auto completion
- tag auto completion
- Comment and uncomment should use same key binding. Editor should be able to check if some text has been commented and execute the corresponding command. Generally, if a selected region containing some lines that are not commented, the command should comment the region, otherwise uncomment it. C-/ is a good key binding for this.
- Go back and forward. In idea, they are bound to C-M-Left and C-M-Right.
- Go to declaration. In emacs, the tag can support this to some extent. Need investigation.
- Last edit position which is pretty much like the above one.
- Document reference support
- Spell checking
- Tab bar. The tabbar design can referred to idea.
- Should provide an unobtrusive way to popup a window displaying a directory structure or type hierarchy etc.
- Support unit test running, comipling and run the application etc.
- More sophiscated ide can support intentional programming.
- Moving is a very common operation. Usually people use mouse to move their cursor. But they can be done using pure keyboard too, emacs does that perfectly. But those moving key bindings should be simple and not be scattered, which means you don’t need to press many keys to move and the switch from moving by word to by sentence or sexp should be very comfortable.
- C-w style marking implemented by IDEA is very nice.
- Delete extra space or empty lines are nice features. They can also be done while formatting the code. And deleting word, sexp or sentence where the cursor is in are also very useful.
Frequent operations should be bound to key bindings that are easy to press. such as copy, paste, cut, delete one line. The key binding should also consider using mouse. Actually, mouse can be very useful. I think the key to be efficient is not that you don’t have to move your hands outside the keyboard to finish all tasks but be able to do what you want by very simple and few steps. If you can use mouse to select a region and your left hand can easily and comfortably perform cut and paste operation, I think that’s better than using C-N or C-P like key combination to select a region.
The design of idea is intentional programming. You do not have to browse the file structure to select the file you want to edit. You can navigate easily while you are thinking, to finish your job you don’t need many mouse clicks and key pressing, that’s partly why people says ecplise is not as good as idea. You just have to click more and press more to finish a job than using idea and Eclipse don’t support you to program smoothly.
The same idea can be applied to emacs. Do it simple. Frequent operations should be able to be done by very simple steps. More unusual operations can be bound to more complex key sequence. For example, moving by sexps in lisps should be simple to do. Moreover, if you don’t want to let your hands leave the keyboard, most moving operations should not need more than 1 key pressing to do it. Like moving by paragraph, the default key binding is C-S-Up or Down, which is good, while you are holding the C and S, you can move the cursor by paragraph as many times as you wish by just pressing up or down. Some other operations like compile, open html file in browser etc. are not very frequently used, so they can be bound to key sequence over 2 key pressing( such as C-c C-v ).
Don’t complain that emacs doesn’t support some ide feature like file structure pane very well. Anyway, we should provide them ,but the important thing is to make programming in emacs don’t need you to use them very often, like in idea.
How to make emacs more comfortable to use
- (done)Swap the caps lock and left control on your dell d610 keyboard, just because the design is bad.
- Kill-buffer command (C-x k) is used very often(at least for me), which can be bound to a more convenient key binding.
- Idea has a nice feature(maybe controversial): when it loses the focus, it saves all open files in its window.
- (done)When a region is selected, pressing Backspace or DEL Should delete the region
- Speedbar should be better too. Refer to the design of textmate.
- Scroll bar. the vertical bar is not necessary, but there should be some convenient way to scroll horizontally.
- Different major modes should be able to have different set of live templates.
- Auto completion
- Unit test support
- (done)Move one line upward or downward
- (done)Duplicate one line
- (done)Delete one line
- (done)Comment and uncomment a region or one line
Here are some key bindings that easy to use:
- <tab>, TAB
- C-, M-, C-M-
- C-c … C-x … C-h …
(M here means ‘alt’ key)
some features that are often forgotten in emacs:
- keyboard macro
The following are some code of those above works that I have marked (done):
<src lang="elisp"> (defun tweakemacs-delete-region-or-char () "Delete a region or a single character." (interactive) (if mark-active (kill-region (region-beginning) (region-end)) (delete-char 1))) (global-set-key (kbd "C-d") 'tweakemacs-delete-region-or-char) (defun tweakemacs-backward-delete-region-or-char () "Backward delete a region or a single character." (interactive) (if mark-active (kill-region (region-beginning) (region-end)) (backward-delete-char 1))) (global-set-key [backspace] 'tweakemacs-backward-delete-region-or-char) (defun tweakemacs-duplicate-one-line () "Duplicate the current line. There is a little bug: when current line is the last line of the buffer, this will not work as expected. Anyway, that's ok for me." (interactive) (let ((start (progn (beginning-of-line) (point))) (end (progn (next-line 1) (beginning-of-line) (point)))) (insert-buffer-substring (current-buffer) start end) (forward-line -1))) (global-set-key (kbd "C-=") 'tweakemacs-duplicate-one-line) (defun tweakemacs-delete-one-line () "Delete current line." (interactive) (beginning-of-line) (kill-line) (kill-line)) (global-set-key "M-o" 'tweakemacs-delete-one-line) (defun tweakemacs-move-one-line-downward () "Move current line downward once." (interactive) (forward-line) (transpose-lines 1) (forward-line -1)) (global-set-key [C-M-down] 'tweakemacs-move-one-line-downward) (defun tweakemacs-move-one-line-upward () "Move current line upward once." (interactive) (transpose-lines 1) (forward-line -2)) (global-set-key [C-M-up] 'tweakemacs-move-one-line-upward) ;; There is a bug in the uncomment-region. When you select ;; the last line of the buffer and if that is a comment, ;; uncomment-region to that region will throw an error: Can't find the comment end. ;; Because I use uncomment-region here, so this command also has this bug. (defun tweakemacs-comment-dwim-region-or-one-line (arg) "When a region exists, execute comment-dwim, or if comment or uncomment the current line according to if the current line is a comment." (interactive "*P") (if mark-active (comment-dwim arg) (save-excursion (let ((has-comment? (progn (beginning-of-line) (looking-at (concat "\s-*" (regexp-quote comment-start)))))) (push-mark (point) nil t) (end-of-line) (if has-comment? (uncomment-region (mark) (point)) (comment-region (mark) (point))))))) (global-set-key (kbd "C-/") 'tweakemacs-comment-dwim-region-or-one-line) </src>